New results on Higgs bosons’ decay into fermions

For a boson to be the Higgs boson, it has to be intimately related to the physical process it was hypothesized in 1964 to help understand. With new results published on June 22, physicists from CERN, the lab that runs the experiments that first discovered the Higgs boson, have found that to be true, further cementing the credibility of their theories as well as discovering more properties that could guide future experiments.

The Higgs boson is too short-lived to be spotted directly. Its lifetime is 10-22 seconds. In this period, it quickly decays into groups of lighter particles. The theory called the Standard Model of particle physics predicts how often the Higgs decays into which groups of particles. Broadly, the rate of this decay is guided by how strongly the Higgs couples to each particle, and such coupling gives rise to the particle’s mass (Note: the Higgs decays only into fundamental particles, not composite particles like protons and neutrons, because it gives mass only to fundamental particles).

The June 22 Letter in Nature Physics describes the champagne bottle boson‘s decay into fermions, the particles that make up all matter. By experimentally finding these rates, physicists accomplish two things. One, they assert the strength of whichever theory predicted these rates – the Standard Model, in this case (the Yukawa couplings, to be specific). Two, they establish that the Higgs boson does couple to fermions and gives them mass. The Letter draws its conclusions from experiments performed in 2011 and 2012.

The third generation of fermions

However, there is a limitation. Because the Higgs weighs 125 GeV, it could only have decayed into lighter fermions, not heavier ones. This means physicists have experimental proof for the Higgs giving mass to fermions lighter than itself; in this case, these are the so-called third generation fermions comprising the bottom quark and the tau lepton. Quarks are fundamental particles that come together to compose protons and neutrons. Leptons are some of the lightest of the matter particles, one common example of which is the electron.

In 2011, the Compact Muon Solenoid (CMS) experimental collaboration, which is the group of scientists that runs the CMS detector, had looked for Higgs bosons decaying into bottom quark-antiquark pairs. At this time, the Large Hadron Collider, which produces these particles by smashing protons together at high speeds, was operating at an energy of 7 TeV – i.e. each beam of protons coming into the collision had an energy of 7 TeV. The consequent results were published in January this year. The 2012 results concerned the search for Higgs bosons’ decays into tau lepton-antilepton pairs at 8 TeV. The pre-print paper submitted to arXiv is here (link to published paper).

The search for these particles is compounded by the fact that they aren’t just produced by the decaying Higgs boson but by a profusion of other Standard Model processes. The scientists at CERN use a combination of statistical techniques to single out which processes produced the particles of interest. They also use as many unique signatures as possible to narrow down their search. For example, the search for the bottom quark-antiquark pair of particles is reconstructed based on a Higgs boson being produced together with a W or a Z boson, whose decays have their own signatures.

The significance at which they report each decay process is in this table, picturized below.

Summary of results for the Higgs boson mass hypothesis of 125 GeV.
Summary of results for the Higgs boson mass hypothesis of 125 GeV.

The Letter, as you can see, is open access, as are all the papers linked to in it.

Higgs boson closer than ever

The article, as written by me, appeared in The Hindu on March 7, 2013.

Ever since CERN announced that it had spotted a Higgs boson-like particle on July 4, 2012, their flagship Large Hadron Collider (LHC), apart from similar colliders around the world, has continued running experiments to gather more data on the elusive particle.

The latest analysis of the results from these runs was presented at a conference now underway in Italy.

While it is still too soon to tell if the one spotted in July 2012 was the Higgs boson as predicted in 1964, the data is convergent toward the conclusion that the long-sought particle does exist and with the expected properties. More results will be presented over the upcoming weeks.

In time, particle physicists hope that it will once and for all close an important chapter in physics called the Standard Model (SM).

The announcements were made by more than 15 scientists from CERN on March 6 via a live webcast from the Rencontres de Moriond, an annual particle physics forum that has been held in La Thuile, Italy, since 1966.

“Since the properties of the new particle appear to be very close to the ones predicted for the SM Higgs, I have personally no further doubts,” Dr. Guido Tonelli, former spokesperson of the CMS detector at CERN, told The Hindu.

Interesting results from searches for other particles, as well as the speculated nature of fundamental physics beyond the SM, were also presented at the forum, which runs from March 2-16.

Physicists exploit the properties of the Higgs to study its behaviour in a variety of environments and see if it matches with the theoretical predictions. A key goal of the latest results has been to predict the strength with which the Higgs couples to other elementary particles, in the process giving them mass.

This is done by analysing the data to infer the rates at which the Higgs-like particle decays into known lighter particles: W and Z bosons, photons, bottom quarks, tau leptons, electrons, and muons. These particles’ signatures are then picked up by detectors to infer that a Higgs-like boson decayed into them.

The SM predicts these rates with good precision.

Thus, any deviation from the expected values could be the first evidence of new, unknown particles. By extension, it would also be the first sighting of ‘new physics’.

Bad news for new physics, good news for old

After analysis, the results were found to be consistent with a Higgs boson of mass near 125-126 GeV, measured at both 7- and 8-TeV collision energies through 2011 and 2012.

The CMS detector observed that there was fairly strong agreement between how often the particle decayed into W bosons and how often it ought to happen according to theory. The ratio between the two was pinned at 0.76 +/- 0.21.

Dr. Tonelli said, “For the moment, we have been able to see that the signal is getting stronger and even the difficult-to-measure decays into bottom quarks and tau-leptons are beginning to appear at about the expected frequency.”

The ATLAS detector, parallely, was able to observe with 99.73 per cent confidence-level that the analysed particle had zero-spin, which is another property that brings it closer to the predicted SM Higgs boson.

At the same time, the detector also observed that the particle’s decay to two photons was 2.3 standard-deviations higher than the SM prediction.

Dr. Pauline Gagnon, a scientist with the ATLAS collaboration, told this Correspondent via email, “We need to asses all its properties in great detail and extreme rigour,” adding that for some aspects they would need more data.

Even so, the developments rule out signs of any new physics around the corner until 2015, when the LHC will reopen after a two-year shutdown and multiple upgrades to smash protons at doubled energy.

As for the search for Supersymmetry, a favoured theoretical concept among physicists to accommodate phenomena that haven’t yet found definition in the Standard Model: Dr. Pierluigi Campana, LHCb detector spokesperson, told The Hindu that there have been only “negative searches so far”.